In Praise of the Scapegoat

Before we get going, quickly do one of the below:

  1. If you are interested in getting first access to new podcasts and my BEST thoughts on how we can have a better future in Western Australia – Pop your email address in the box and click Sign Up
  2. If you like to Watch Videos – Click the Youtube Icon or Instagram Icon and chuck us a subscribe/ follow. 
  3. If you Like to Listen – Click the Spotify, Itunes, or Google Podcast Icon and Click Subscribe

Note: All views expressed in this podcast are Former Mayor Penny Taylors and do not represent the views of Subiaco Council itself.


Subiaco is a city suburb centred on the hustle and bustle of small boutiques and high end shopping, stylish cafe’s, wine bars and gastropubs. But beneath the hustle and bustle and liveliness of Subiaco is a huge amount of debilitations threatening the city’s liveliness. 

In this episode, I’m continuing my chat with the Former Mayor of Subiaco Penny Taylor. In part one, Penny revealed a massive amount of dysfunction in Subiaco Council. If you are yet to listen to part one, make sure you go back to listen that episode first. In part two, we will be diving deeper into the dysfunction. We talk about the impacts on Penny herself, and also on the community as a whole in Subiaco along with the potential solutions to change things for the better going forwards. 


In the ep you’ll find out about:

  1. Local Governments lack of code of conduct 
  2. The changes being made for Subiaco’s future
  3. The false dichotomy in Subiaco
  4. Why Subiaco Counsellors don’t take the blame for the current dysfunction

And more…


Discussion Points:

00:00 Introduction 

02:04 The false dichotomy in Subiaco

02:30 Business becoming marginal in Subiaco

06:43 The motion of no confidence meeting

13:41 Post football plan

19:15 Obstacles to getting things done

20:14 The impact of dysfunction to Subiaco itself 

15:53 The impact to Penny the Mayor

28:06 The impact to Penny the person

32:47 The obstacle and impacts on the people of Subi

34:57 Advice to the people of Subiaco/incoming Mayor 


About The Guest

Penny Taylor is the former Mayor to The City of Subiaco. Penny completed her studies as geologist at Sydney University before moving to the Pilbara to work in the mining industry. Throughout Penny’s career in mining she worked across project management and following mining she, together with her husband started a family business servicing the resources industry. Following this, Penny then moved to Perth to start a family. 

Penny’s move to government started when she worked as a counsellor at the town of Port Hedland and ran for the seat of Nedlands in the 2017 State Election. It was this experience in Port Hedland that promoted Penny to run for Mayor of Subiaco in 2017, a role which she held until 2021. 

Aside from Government, Penny is also involved in a number of organisations including the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation, UWA Little Athletics and Rosalie Primary School to name a few. 


Click to watch on YouTube

Listen to the audio podcast here

Worried that good faith will get you fleeced? Need to get more contractual with your clients? Meet the unlikely hero here to save your hide. 

Like a bolt from the blue, a couple of buddies you haven’t seen since your Uni days have got in touch. Want to join them for 18 holes and a burger? Of course you do! 

…just, not this Saturday. Man United are facing off against Liverpool and you have a prior commitment to the living room couch.

You don’t want to upset these guys. You want them to know that you’re really keen, protect what could be a very valuable friendship. You’d genuinely love to go with them another day. 

But… you’ve been looking forward to this match since the start of the season. And you’re not sure they’d understand playing second fiddle to a TV screen. 

So what do you do? 

You phone in a scapegoat. Your significant other wants you home. Or you have to look after the toddler. Perhaps you’re helping a mate move house.

Let’s be real here for a moment: honesty is always the best policy. But when people’s feelings are on the line, the scapegoat is the oldest trick in the book for a reason – it works.

No alt text provided for this image

A Simple Solution

With Football on Saturday a distant memory, you’re back to the real world. Your company is about to hit ‘go’ on another project. The client is the real bread-and-butter kind – a Big Name, with Big Business to show for it. They’ve been keeping you guys fed and watered for the best part of a decade. 

But you recently heard rumblings about a similar project with a different contractor that went to hell in a hand basket. The big-name client decided not to pay, for what sounded like basically no reason. Arbitration happened, litigation nearly happened and it all sounded like a world of pain. 

So as much as you’d like to be feeling optimistic – well, you’re not. This critical relationship lies in your hands. And you’re sweating. 

How do you keep the client on-side, but subtly make sure that your company doesn’t end up in financial ruin?

You call your friendly neighbourhood scapegoat, of course: a third-party consultancy that doesn’t rely on your client’s undying affection.

No alt text provided for this image

The Benefits of a Scapegoat

Hi Very Important Client, we’ve engaged a company to keep an eye on our contractual obligations so we can concentrate on what we’re here for – doing the best job we can for you. 

Engaging a consultancy (scapegoat) effectively involves some clear, honest communication – you need to be as up-front as possible.

That’s because, from your client’s perspective, your company doing any of these things can potentially raise a red flag: 

  • Suddenly becoming more contractual part-way through a project
  • Appearing to have little or no awareness of the contract at all
  • Changing processes part-way through – especially when it comes to capturing changes to scope/potential variations

It’s a balancing act. It can be really tough if you’ve worked with the client before and they’ve become used to a particular style of management. But as long as you’re up-front about it, the idea of bringing on a consultancy shouldn’t cause anyone any lack of sleep. In many situations, it makes sense. Look at it this way – does your company need an excuse (or anyone’s permission) to review and optimise processes? Of course not. 

For this project, we had a look at making the most of the resources we had to do the best possible job. As it turns out, the most efficient solution meant outsourcing the contract side of things to another company.

Once you’ve managed to explain the new situation – and reassure your client that things shouldn’t change for them too much – you’ve earned yourself some breathing space. 

No alt text provided for this image

You CAN Have Your Cake and Eat it, Too

I’m assuming you want all of these things to happen:

  • You do a great job for the client
  • You forget about the contract and focus on work, knowing that no fine print is going to come back to bite you
  • The client has a great experience working for you and still feels the love

With a consultancy, none of these are mutually exclusive. 

If your company has been lax in the past and wants to come down a little harder to protect its best interests, this is the perfect way. Any change in the way things are done can easily be ‘blamed’ on the consultancy. You’re still friendly and accommodating. It’s the consultancy, not you, that wants that change captured in writing, or more detail added to the scope of works before it’s signed off. 

Too easy.

No alt text provided for this image

The Long and the Short of it

There’s been a shift in the way the bigger companies have been doing business lately. Like it or lump it, they’re getting more contractual. 

It is something of a self-fulfilling prophecy. Aware of a general trend towards an increase in claims and disputes, these companies bring more people on board to help ensure that it doesn’t happen to them. In turn, this means that there are more eyes on the contract – creating more potential for disputes in the first place. And if you think you need to be more contractual to match, then you almost certainly do. 

Change is tough. But it’s a LOT easier when someone’s there to play ‘bad cop’ for you.

So while other contractors might just take the gamble, you can be smarter than that. 

Step 1: get your goat. 

Step 2: relax.

No alt text provided for this image
Scroll to Top